Understanding the user (20 points):
-Three unique and distinct users that are representative of the population (3)
-One profile is an expert user (2)

For each profile (3*5)

The profile sounds like it is describing an actual person, not just a general category (2)
Items such as age, family status, education level, occupation, interests, etc are mentioned (1)
User profile is appropriate and relevant to the design problem (2)

Understanding the task (20 points)
For each scenario

In general, the interaction scenario is convincing and realistic (3)
User motivations are specified (3)
Specified which media devices they want to use and how (3)
What are the distraction and how they effect the current task (3)
Examples of slips and mistakes are given (4)
Scenarios are presented in a narrative format (4)

Device, form, function, and layout (40 points)
The basic design of the remote is usable and convincing (10)
The design satisfies all users (10)
Affordances, Mappings, and Constraints are discussed, where appropriate, and presented meaningfully (15)
Sketches of Device are given (5)

Writing (20 points)
Grammar is complete, clear, and coherent (10)
Typos and no misspelled / misused words (10)

>95 = 1,0
90 = 1,3
85 = 1,7
80 = 2,0
75 = 2,3
70 = 2,7
65 = 3,0
60 = 3,3
55 = 3,7
50 = 4,0
45 = 4,3
40 = 4,0
<35 = 5,0